Дорогомиловский суд по лондонскому делу

Dorogomilovsky Court vs. English High Court

  • Sovcomflot has not commented on the verdict of the Dorogomolovsky Court in Moscow that sentenced former Sovcomflot and Novoship top managers, Yury Nikitin, Dmitry Skarga and Tagir Izmailov, to various prison terms in absentia.

    SeaNews has asked Mike Lax, Partner with Lax & Co, the lawyer who represented Yury Nikitin in the English High Court, to comment on the judgement. Quoting:

    Dorogomilovsky Court vs. English High Court“I’m afraid I haven’t seen any judgment of the Dorogomilovsky Court so it is difficult to comment in detail. I recall that the allegations in the Dorogomilovsky Court looked very similar to some of the allegations made against the same Defendants in the English High Court.  You will recall that with the exception of some of the commission claims made against Mr Nikitin, Clarksons and Galbraiths, all of those allegations by Sovcomflot were dismissed by the English High Court as well as by the Court of Appeal.  Indeed, the English High Court and Court of Appeal even went so far as to Order Sovcomflot to pay compensation to Mr Niktin of approximately $75 million for wrongfully freezing Mr Nikitin’s assets”.

    “So if the Dorogomilovsky Court has now found Mr Nikitin guilty of being the head of a criminal gang that defrauded Sovcomflot and for which he should serve 15 years, it is a curious state of affairs that the victims of the crime should be ordered by the English High Court to pay the head of the criminal gang $75m. One of the Courts must therefore be in error. Which one?”

    “Well, the English High Court heard oral and written evidence from numerous witnesses and from experts instructed by both sides; the Judge was a very experienced shipping and commercial judge; a transcript of the proceedings was published every day for everyone to review; and at the end of the case, the judge published a judgment which was fully reasoned and summarised the evidence; it was a few hundred pages long”.

    “The Moscow Court was by contrast presided over by a Judge whose knowledge and experience of shipping contracts governed by English Law is unknown; experts in shipping and accounting were not apparently called to give evidence and be cross-examined; there was no transcript and we have seen no judgment let alone detailed reasoning.  We leave it to your readers to decide which of the Courts most likely got it right and which got it wrong”.

    According to reports, this Monday the Dorogomilovsky Court announced its verdict, according to which the defendants were found guilty of organizing and participating in a criminal gang, abuse of authority, misappropriation and legalizing of monetary proceeds of the crime. Y.Nikitin was sentenced to 15 years in prison, D.Skarga to 12 years and T.Izmailov to 11 years. The Court also imposed upon them fines ranging from 2.5 mn rubles to 5 mn rubles and ordered their property arrested earlier (money, stock, flats) to be seized.

  • Comments: 0

    Leave a Reply

    Related content
    Sovcomflot and Rosnefteflot signed an agreement whereby SCF’s specialists will provide technical supervision during the construction of Rosneft’s […]
    Sovcomflot’s LNG tanker loads the first cargo
    Sovcomflot has secured $106 mn from Sberbank for up to 14 years to finance the construction of a […]
    Sovcomflot has posted financial results for 2017 according to the IFRS accounting standards. The group’s gross revenue increased […]
    The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom has refused Sovcomflot a permission to appeal
    From Zvezda Shipbuilding Complex with financing from VEB
    The Board of Novoship has elected Alexey Khaidukov President of the company. He will replace Yury Tsvetkov, who […]
    To finance LNG-powered Aframax tankers cobstruction
    SCF Group has published its financial results for the third quarter and nine months of 2018. For Q3, […]
    On 30 October at 23:59 Moscow time, “Lomonosov Prospect”, Sovcomflot’s second large-capacity tanker using LNG fuel as its […]
    The Board of Sovcomflot at their meeting yesterday in Moscow considered the company’s financial plan for 2019 and […]
    March 12, Sovcomflot’s tanker “Viktor Konetsky” took on board the 100-millionth ton of crude oil from the Sakhalin […]
  • Fields marker by * are required

    Order research

  • Login
  • Fields marker by * are required

    Buy a subscription for the regular maritime analytical materials of the  Russian Federation

  • Fields marker by * are required

    Buy Subscription for Foreign Trade via Russian Ports Analysis Online Service